Order entry from email, fax, and PDF
$75,704 / year
Reads an emailed, faxed, or PDF order and drafts it for a person to approve.
234 hours/month
10ofYou.ai · Equity Hammer
AI Utilization Test
Prepared by Will Christensen for Mason Kramer, President.
Houston, Texas
This is an outside read for Mason Kramer. Fifty-three public criteria are scored 2, 1, 0, or unknown. Unknowns are left out of the grade, not counted as misses. A category needs at least three known criteria before it gets a letter. The dollar figure is a separate estimate of six back-office workflows. It uses your numbers and published benchmarks. It is not a claim about what another dealer saved. The letters stay as scored.
The dollar lines are estimates from public pages and published benchmarks.
Overall grade
C+
63.5% of scored points. 75% coverage (40 of 53).
Estimated annual savings
$161,318
$59,967–$270,685 a year
Estimates based on your inputs and published industry benchmarks.
$75,704 / year
Reads an emailed, faxed, or PDF order and drafts it for a person to approve.
234 hours/month
$31,871 / year
Lists accounts whose orders have gone quiet, for someone to call.
8 hours/month
$24,746 / year
Applies vendor cost changes to the price file at month-end, for a person to approve.
8 hours/month
Six figures. They are prefilled from public pages or marked as an assumption. Change one and the workflow dollars follow. Nothing is saved.
Reads as $13,000,000
Point: Independent Dealer, June 2024, “Annual sales: $13 million,” after the Anything Office purchase. Low: a LinkedIn aggregate of about $7 million. High: an allowance for the supply division bought in May 2026, whose revenue is not disclosed. Current revenue is not stated.
Published range on file: $7,000,000–$16,000,000
Assumption
Derived. $13 million divided by an assumed $150 average order is about 86,700 orders a year, or 347 a business day. The low and high on file are 93 and 711. The $150 order size is an assumption, anchored to a $75 free-shipping threshold and small example orders on the site.
Published range on file: 93 orders–711 orders
The 2024 profile says 80% online, so 20% is not. A fax number is published as an order channel, and school or bid paperwork arrives by email or fax. Enter 20 for 20%.
Published range on file: 12–30%
Inferred from named customer-care roles in the trade press and chamber listings, plus a LinkedIn split that shows 2 of 9 profiles in customer service. The range on file is 3 to 7.
Published range on file: 3 people–7 people
Not disclosed. Zuma+ is a priced program for customers spending $500 or more a month, and schools buy on terms. Enter 25 for 25%. It only splits the pricing estimate between month-end cost updates and contract drift.
Published range on file: 10–40%
Houston-area customer-service median $18.90 an hour (BLS OEWS, May 2024), divided by the BLS finding that wages are 70.1% of compensation. 18.90 / 0.701 = $26.96.
Other prospects: Blaisdell's Business ProductsThe Office TexA-Z Office ResourceIQ Total Source
Estimates based on your inputs and published industry benchmarks. Not a claim about what another dealer saved.
Typical estimate for a dealer of about this size. Not a client result, and not a claim about what any dealer saved.
Reads an emailed, faxed, or PDF order and drafts it for a person to approve.
Your estimate
234 hours/month
$75,704 / year
$39,254–$105,144
Typical estimate
374.4 hours/month
179.5–520 hours/month
$175,219 / year
$87,325–$243,360
Orders per day times 250 business days times the share that still arrives by phone, fax, or email. The gap between a manual order and an electronic order is the APQC range: $10 to $16.50 manual, $4 electronic, midpoint $13.25. A 2% keying-error rate times a $50 rework assumption is added to the dollars only. We count 60% of that gap, and we never count more than 45% of customer-care time. Hours are the keying portion, excluding rework, divided by your loaded wage.
The smaller of: manual orders × (manual cost − electronic cost + error rework) × 60%, and people × loaded wage × 2,080 hours × 45% × 60%. Hours use the keying gap only, divided by the loaded wage.
Builds yesterday's sales and margin report from an export, overnight.
Your estimate
12.1 hours/month
$3,925 / year
$1,402–$9,533
Typical estimate
15.2 hours/month
6.5–36.8 hours/month
$7,098 / year
$3,042–$17,238
Five hours a week to assemble the report by hand, times 52, times 70% removed, priced at your loaded wage. The hours are an assumption. The wage is yours. This is desk time, not recovered margin.
Hours a week × 52 × 70% × loaded wage. Hours a month are that time divided by 12.
Lists accounts whose orders have gone quiet, for someone to call.
Your estimate
8 hours/month
$31,871 / year
$6,192–$56,659
Typical estimate
8 hours/month
4–16 hours/month
$81,720 / year
$15,588–$155,268
Zilliant's distribution benchmark puts median customer churn at 9.08% of revenue (low 4.33%; the high case stays at the median). Their note says companies recapture 5% to 15% of that loss. We use 10%, then keep the gross-margin share of it. Hours are a separate assumption, about two hours a week to pull the list. The dollars are margin, not hours times the wage.
Revenue × churn rate × 10% recaptured × gross margin. Hours are a fixed 8 a month.
Checks a vendor invoice against the purchase order for a price or quantity mismatch.
Your estimate
52 hours/month
$16,823 / year
$8,972–$50,469
Typical estimate
104 hours/month
55.5–234 hours/month
$48,672 / year
$25,958–$109,512
Customer orders times 0.20 supplier invoices per order. Ardent Partners puts the average invoice at $9.40 to process and best-in-class at $2.78 (the high case uses their 'all others' figure of $12.88). We count 60% of that gap, and we never count more than half of accounting time. The benchmark is the cost to process an invoice. It is not a counted rate of price or quantity errors. Hours are those dollars divided by your loaded wage.
The smaller of: invoices × ($9.40 − $2.78) × 60%, and accounting seats × loaded wage × 2,080 × 50% × 60%.
Applies vendor cost changes to the price file at month-end, for a person to approve.
Your estimate
8 hours/month
$24,746 / year
$3,110–$36,660
Typical estimate
8 hours/month
4–12 hours/month
$59,220 / year
$7,308–$93,765
Zilliant's 'misaligned market pricing' median is 2.35% of annual margin (low 0.58%; the high case stays at 2.35%). We apply that to gross profit, count 40% as recoverable, then keep the share of revenue that is not on a contract price. Hours are a separate assumption, about a day a month on the cost file. The dollars are margin, not hours times the wage. Moving the contract share shifts dollars between this row and contract drift. It does not change the sum of the two.
Revenue × gross margin × 2.35% leak × 40% recovered × (1 − contract share).
Flags contract prices that have moved off the agreed price.
Your estimate
4 hours/month
$8,249 / year
$1,037–$12,220
Typical estimate
4 hours/month
2–8 hours/month
$25,380 / year
$3,132–$40,185
The same Zilliant pricing leak as month-end cost updates, applied only to the share of revenue you say is on a contract price. Hours are a separate assumption, about half a day a month. The dollars are margin on that share. This is not a measured error rate from a contract file.
Revenue × gross margin × 2.35% leak × 40% recovered × contract share.
Total
Your estimate
$161,318 / year
$59,967–$270,685
318.1 hours/month
Typical estimate
$397,309 / year
$142,353–$659,328
513.6 hours/month
Business days in a year250
A 2,080-hour year divided by 8. Turns orders per day into orders per year.
SourceCost of one manual order$13.25 (range $10–$16.50)
APQC figures cited by Modern Distribution Management: a manual order costs $10 to $16.50. We use the midpoint.
SourceCost of one electronic order$4
APQC electronic-channel median, via the same write-up. APQC's broader 'manage sales orders' median is $8.48.
SourceError rate on hand-keyed orders2% (range 0.95%–3%)
Barchard and Pace 2011 measured 0.95% on single entry. Trade write-ups put hand keying at 1–3%. We use 2%.
SourceRework cost per order error$50 (range $25–$75)
Assumption. No public dealer benchmark for the credit, reship, and desk time on one bad order.
Share of the manual-order gap we count60% (range 40%–75%)
Assumption. Vendor claims run higher. We haircut them.
Cap: customer-care time that is order entry45% (range 35%–50%)
Assumption. A sanity cap so order entry cannot consume the whole desk. The dollar line cannot exceed this share of customer-care time, times the capture rate.
Gross margin27% (range 22%–32%)
General office-products band. The mix is online commodity, janitorial, and MRO, with a published price-match promise. Not a figure from the books.
SourceMargin lost to prices that lag cost2.35% of gross profit (low 0.58%; high held at 2.35%)
Zilliant 2024 distribution benchmark, 'Misaligned Market Pricing': 10th / median / 90th = 0.58% / 2.35% / 5.73% of annual margin. The high case stays at the median, not the 90th percentile. Applied to gross-profit dollars.
SourceShare of that pricing leak a check recovers40% (range 25%–50%)
Assumption.
Annual revenue lost to churn9.08% of revenue (low 4.33%; high held at 9.08%)
Zilliant 2024 distribution benchmark, 'Customer Churn': 10th / median / 90th. The high case stays at the median. Includes silent category drop-off in their definition.
SourceShare of churned revenue a win-back list recaptures10% (range 5%–15%)
Zilliant's note that companies recapture five to 15 percent of this revenue loss. We use 10%. The dollars are gross margin on that slice, not wages.
SourceSupplier invoices per customer order0.25 (range 0.10–0.50)
Assumption. Orders are described as going to the warehouses quickly, and some freight ships from the maker. The 2024 wholesaler was Essendant, which later left the independent channel. The current wholesaler is not stated.
SourceCost to process one supplier invoice$9.40 (high case $12.88)
Ardent Partners, State of ePayables 2024: average $9.40, all-others $12.88, best-in-class $2.78. This is processing cost, not a counted rate of price or quantity mismatches.
SourceBest-in-class cost per supplier invoice$2.78
Ardent Partners, State of ePayables 2024, best-in-class.
SourceShare of the invoice-cost gap an audit closes60% (range 40%–75%)
Assumption.
Accounting staff1 person (range 1–2)
Independent Dealer lists a vice president of accounting. LinkedIn shows one finance profile. The high allows for a larger book after the 2026 purchase.
SourceCap: accounting time on supplier invoices50% (range 40%–60%)
Assumption. A sanity cap so invoice work cannot consume the whole accounting desk.
Hours a week assembling the sales and margin report4 hours/week (range 2–8)
Assumption for a 13-person firm on a hosted store. Several locations now have to be rolled up: Houston, Lenoir, Southern Pines, Raleigh, and Boone.
Share of that reporting time a nightly report removes70% (range 50%–85%)
Assumption. Someone still reads the report.
Hours a month to pull a lapsed-account list8 hours/month (range 4–16)
Assumption. About two hours a week. The dollar line is recovered margin, not these hours times the wage.
Hours a month on the cost-file update8 hours/month (range 4–12)
Assumption. The dollar line is recovered margin on the off-contract book, not these hours times the wage.
Hours a month checking contract prices4 hours/month (range 2–8)
Assumption. The dollar line is recovered margin on the contract share, not these hours times the wage.
How a pilot is run. No certification and no uptime figure.
Nothing is sent to a customer, and nothing is changed in the system, until someone on your team says yes.
The first step reads reports and exports. It does not write orders, prices, or invoices.
No customer-facing chatbot and no phone prompt. The work stays behind the desk.
It reads exports from the Logicblock store. Nothing is ripped out and replaced.
The data stays yours. Access can be turned off at any time.
Pick one of the six. The others wait until that one is useful.
C+ overall, 63.5% of the points on criteria we could score, 75% coverage. Unknown criteria are left out of the denominator. A category with fewer than three known criteria has no letter. The letters do not move when you edit Your Business. Dollar estimates are on Common Workflows.
checklist v2: category pct = points / (2 x known criteria); unknowns excluded; category needs >=3 known criteria; overall = mean of graded category pct
Overall
C+
63.5% · 75% coverage
1.1B2B webstore with customer accounts, cart and checkout
2 passOwn Logicblock webstore with sign-in, My Account, cart and checkout (/login.aspx, /checkout/checkout.aspx, /myaccount); product pages show price and Add to Cart
1.2Punch-out / eProcurement catalog confirmed on a named buyer platform
0 missNo punch-out / cXML / eProcurement catalog on own site; no buyer punch-out list names Zuma (web search 2026-11-18)
1.3Purchase orders captured at checkout rather than emailed as documents
1 partialApproved-account POs can be placed on the website OR by phone, fax or email; no-account POs must be faxed/emailed as signed documents
1.4Fax is not an ordering channel
0 missContact page: 'Fax*: 1-512-593-5596 *You may fax in orders at this number'; school PO page also directs faxed orders
1.5Job posts (current or last 3 yrs) do NOT list manual keying of phone/fax/email orders
unknownNo Zuma job posts found on Indeed/LinkedIn/own site (searched 2026-11-18)
No public source
1.6Company-stated online share of orders or revenue
1 partialCompany-stated 80% of business online (Independent Dealer, Jun 2024)
1.7Self-serve ordering is the primary path (phone/email secondary)
1 partialPhone, 'Chat live' and email shown beside the cart as equal channels; site promises 'Customer Service that really listens (and answers the phone)'; schools/government order by phone, fax or email
Not enough of this category could be scored from outside, so it has no letter. The criteria we could see are still listed.
2.1Contract vehicles on own site match the public registry (number, schedule/SIN, dates)
unknownNo contract vehicles (GSA, cooperative) published on own site, so nothing to compare with a registry
No public source
2.2Contract terms pages free of stale or third-party boilerplate
2 passZuma+ page, school/government PO page and Terms read clean and consistent (Net 30, $500 monthly minimum, free shipping $45 for Zuma+). Stale items found elsewhere are scored under 5.6/4.3, not here
2.3No public price-change or price-discrepancy complaint in the last 3 years (BBB + review sites readable)
unknownBBB profile not readable (403) and Yelp/eKomi show no price complaints but BBB is required by the criterion
2.4Contract/government item numbers consistent between listing URL and page (sample >=4)
unknownOnly 2 product pages readable in Wayback (ProMist mop FHD173563EA; Xerox drum XER013R00603); both URL suffix = Item # = JSON-LD sku. Sample < 4 so left unknown
2.5Price upkeep stated as systematic (feeds, automated monitoring) rather than manual review
unknownPrice-upkeep method not stated (Price Guarantee says 'Zuma compares our prices' and asks customers to email if they see a lower price)
2.6Fee, surcharge and shipping-threshold policies consistent across pages
0 missFAQ says $8.99 shipping under $75 and $69.95 / 10% freight; Shipping Policy says $9.99 ($45-75), $13.99 (<$45) and $84.95 / 13% freight. Both captured 25 May 2022; FAQ text unchanged in Jul 2025; no later readable Shipping Policy capture
3.1Customer accounts show order history with reorder
unknownOrder History with status and tracking exists; a 'reorder' button is not described and product pages could not be inspected while signed in
3.2Saved lists/favorites and standing or managed replenishment offered
1 partialFavorites lists and Quick Order form offered; no standing/managed replenishment program described (product-page template carries subscription styling but no offer text was visible)
3.3Email marketing platform in use (detectable on site)
2 passAct-On email platform forms (email.zumaoffice.com/acton) and promotional newsletters stated in Terms
3.4Evidence of automated lifecycle email (abandoned cart, reorder reminder, win-back)
unknownLifecycle emails (abandoned cart, reorder reminders) not observable without placing orders
No public source
3.5Loyalty, referral or volume-rebate program published
2 passZuma+ volume-pricing program (5-15% off 11,000+ items at $500/mo), Awin affiliate/referral program, manufacturer-rebate page
3.6Named / assigned account rep for business customers advertised
2 passZuma+ advertises a 'Dedicated Solution Specialist'; NC chamber/NCADA pages name Senior Solution Specialists
3.7Post-purchase review solicitation in place (review platform or steady review flow)
2 passeKomi review platform: 6,094 total reviews, 32 in last 12 months; '4.7/5 Guaranteed Real Customer Feedback' widget in footer
4.1Customers can view invoices/statements online
unknown'Paperless email invoicing' for payment-term customers; online invoice/statement viewing not stated
4.2Net terms / credit set up digitally (instant online credit or online application)
1 partialSchools/government: create account, then contact customer service to finish setup (Net 30); Zuma+ customers 'may apply for 30-day invoicing'; business terms via credit application forwarded by email
4.3Payment and financing pages current and consistent
1 partialFAQ (Jul 2025) still lists 'Amazon Checkout' (Checkout by Amazon ended in the U.S. in April 2017) and money orders/cashier's checks before shipment
4.4Job posts (current or last 3 yrs) do NOT list hand entry of payments, invoices or billing
unknownNo accounting/billing job posts found
No public source
4.5Webstore connected to back-office data (live stock/pricing from ERP)
2 passLogicblock hosted store with wholesaler-catalog integrations (Logicblock case study); product JSON-LD carries live price + InStock; FAQ: orders are transmitted to warehouses almost immediately
4.6No public billing-error complaints in the last 3 years (BBB + reviews readable)
unknownBBB not readable; no billing complaints seen on eKomi/Yelp, but criterion needs BBB
5.1Address identical across own pages and own structured data (incl. geo pin)
1 partialOwn Contact page: 'based in beautiful Houston' with corporate address '5350 Bellaire Blvd. Unit 2047, Bellaire TX 77401'; FAQ says HQ in Houston; Organization JSON-LD has no address. Other listings: 314 Garden Oaks Blvd Houston 77018 (eKomi, ISG, PitchBook), 'PO Box 2047 Bellaire 77402-2047' (Caldwell Chamber)
5.2Phone numbers consistent across own site and major listings
1 partialOwn site consistent (877-473-4097; fax 512-593-5596). Listings differ: Yahoo/LinkedIn (512) 373-8079 Austin; ISG +1 713-337-8927; Moore County Chamber (910) 692-6631; NCADA 919-464-4031
5.3Chamber / association listings current
1 partialMoore County Chamber (Southern Pines) still describes 'a locally owned and independent office supply store' and lists three contact names that do not appear on Zuma's pages; Caldwell Chamber PO-box ZIP 77402 vs own 77401; Catawba and Downtown Lenoir listings current
5.4Map / place listings correct (category, address, hours)
1 partialYahoo Local and Birdeye show Zuma at 3401 Fritz Hughes Park Dr, Austin TX 78732 (Birdeye unclaimed) with an old '50% of profits' / '40,000 products' description; LinkedIn lists Houston plus Austin office; Houston-only listings elsewhere
5.5Catalog size and years-in-business claims consistent across own pages
1 partialFounding year conflict: live /our-story, WJ press release, LinkedIn and PitchBook say 2004; archived /our-story (to at least 2022), Independent Dealer 2024 and Logicblock showcase (Mar 2026) say Dec 2009. Catalog claims also vary (26,000 in 2009; 40,000 on Yahoo; '2000,000' typo on LinkedIn)
5.6No defunct or stale content live (dead services, old partners, retired systems)
0 missTwo stale items on latest readable captures (Jul 2025): footer 'Half of Profits Go to Charity!' and FAQ/affiliate '50%' text vs 10% on the header and live /our-story; FAQ lists the defunct 'Amazon Checkout'. Footer 'Blogs' link goes to a charity blog whose last post is Aug 2021. Live footer not verifiable (Cloudflare)
5.7Structured data (Organization/LocalBusiness) correct on core facts
1 partialOrganization JSON-LD present with only name, url and logo (no address, phone, sameAs or areaServed). Product pages carry full Product/Offer JSON-LD
5.8Descriptive page titles on main pages
2 passDescriptive titles: 'Office Products & Discount Janitorial Supplies Online - ZumaOffice.com', 'Zuma Price Guarantee - Zuma', 'Zuma Business Class Contract Program - Office Supplies Savings - Zuma', 'Zuma Accepts Purchase Orders from Schools and Government Agencies! - Zuma'
6.1Live chat on site
2 pass'Chat live' link opens Zendesk (zopim) chat on every page
6.2Published weekday support hours
1 partialOffice hours 8:30 am-5:00 pm Central, Mon-Fri (8.5 h)
6.3After-hours or weekend coverage (staffed, bot, or stated SLA)
0 missBusiness hours only; no after-hours channel stated
6.4Self-serve order history/status online
2 passTrack Order (order number + ZIP) and My Orders / Order History with tracking number and status
6.5Self-serve help: FAQ and returns process online
2 passFAQ page plus Returns page and ReturnForm.aspx ('No Hassle Returns')
6.6Independent review rating
1 partialeKomi 4.3/5 from 32 reviews in last 12 months (95.9% positive); 6,094 lifetime. Yelp via Yahoo 4.0 on 5 reviews
6.7Owner replies to public customer reviews
unknownOwner replies to reviews not visible on eKomi/Yelp pages read
No public source
6.8Recent independent review flow (last 12 months)
2 pass32 eKomi reviews in the last 12 months (latest Aug 3 2026)
7.1Customer-facing purchase/spend reports advertised
1 partialOrder history plus 'set budgets' (FAQ); no spend reports advertised
7.2Multi-user accounts with budget/approval controls
2 passZuma+: 'Unlimited users, spend controls, order approvals'; FAQ: multiple users, permissions, budgets
7.3Contract/government sales reporting stated as automated
unknownGovernment/contract sales reporting method not stated
No public source
7.4Named operations leader (COO / GM / ops manager)
1 partialMason Kramer is listed as President and COO in one directory and President and CEO in another, so the operations title is publicly unclear.
7.5Live stock/availability shown to customers
2 passProduct pages show 'Estimated Delivery: 1-2 Business Days' and JSON-LD availability InStock
8.1Share of tested buyer-style AI queries naming the company
1 partialNamed in 1 of 4 buyer-style queries (charity-giving query); not named for 'best online office supply Houston', 'bulk janitorial/breakroom free shipping', or 'auto dealer key tags/windshield highlights'. Factual query 'who owns Zuma' named it (2026-11-18)
scorecard 8 (AI test, 2026-11-18)
8.2Facts in AI answers about the company correct
0 missAn AI answer repeated an older charity share. The company's current pages say 10%.
scorecard 8 (AI test, 2026-11-18)
8.3Organization/LocalBusiness structured data present
2 passOrganization JSON-LD present on home page
8.4All served markets represented (areaServed / city pages)
unknownNo areaServed data and no readable city/location pages (/Locations referenced in WJ release returns 403 live, not archived)
No public source
8.5No review markup that violates search guidelines (self-serving aggregateRating)
2 passNo aggregateRating or review markup in home or product JSON-LD
8.6Buyer-question content published in the last 12 months (guides/FAQ/blog)
0 missCharity blog last posted Aug 3 2021; no guides/FAQ articles in the last 12 months found
Each line is a public signal, scored 2, 1, 0, or unknown. Unknowns are not treated as failures. Where the pages disagree, that is an inconsistency we noticed, not a verdict on the people who answer the phone. An agent, in this read, is back-office help so those people get more of the day on the phone.
Some of these pages were not readable live. Where that is so, the comparison uses archived snapshots, mostly from 2022 and 2025.
The inconsistencies on the company’s own pages.
An archived footer says half of profits go to charity, and an archived FAQ says the same. The live story page and a 2024 trade-press quote say 10% of net profits. We noticed the conflict. We are not saying which line you intend today.
The archived FAQ says $8.99 under $75, and freight of $69.95 or 10%. The archived shipping policy says $9.99 between $45 and $75, $13.99 under $45, and freight of $84.95 or 13%. Both snapshots are from May 2022, and the FAQ text was still there in July 2025. The live pages were not readable, so we cannot see which table is current.
The live story page says 2004. The archived story page, the 2024 trade profile, and a March 2026 vendor page say December 2009. LinkedIn also says 2004. Addresses also differ: the contact page says 5350 Bellaire Blvd., Unit 2047, Bellaire 77401; a chamber lists PO Box 2047, Bellaire 77402; other directories list 314 Garden Oaks Blvd., Houston 77018.
Listings and page facts that do not match, from the online-presence checklist.
5.1Address identical across own pages and own structured data (incl. geo pin)
1 partialOwn Contact page: 'based in beautiful Houston' with corporate address '5350 Bellaire Blvd. Unit 2047, Bellaire TX 77401'; FAQ says HQ in Houston; Organization JSON-LD has no address. Other listings: 314 Garden Oaks Blvd Houston 77018 (eKomi, ISG, PitchBook), 'PO Box 2047 Bellaire 77402-2047' (Caldwell Chamber)
5.2Phone numbers consistent across own site and major listings
1 partialOwn site consistent (877-473-4097; fax 512-593-5596). Listings differ: Yahoo/LinkedIn (512) 373-8079 Austin; ISG +1 713-337-8927; Moore County Chamber (910) 692-6631; NCADA 919-464-4031
5.3Chamber / association listings current
1 partialMoore County Chamber (Southern Pines) still describes 'a locally owned and independent office supply store' and lists three contact names that do not appear on Zuma's pages; Caldwell Chamber PO-box ZIP 77402 vs own 77401; Catawba and Downtown Lenoir listings current
5.4Map / place listings correct (category, address, hours)
1 partialYahoo Local and Birdeye show Zuma at 3401 Fritz Hughes Park Dr, Austin TX 78732 (Birdeye unclaimed) with an old '50% of profits' / '40,000 products' description; LinkedIn lists Houston plus Austin office; Houston-only listings elsewhere
5.5Catalog size and years-in-business claims consistent across own pages
1 partialFounding year conflict: live /our-story, WJ press release, LinkedIn and PitchBook say 2004; archived /our-story (to at least 2022), Independent Dealer 2024 and Logicblock showcase (Mar 2026) say Dec 2009. Catalog claims also vary (26,000 in 2009; 40,000 on Yahoo; '2000,000' typo on LinkedIn)
5.6No defunct or stale content live (dead services, old partners, retired systems)
0 missTwo stale items on latest readable captures (Jul 2025): footer 'Half of Profits Go to Charity!' and FAQ/affiliate '50%' text vs 10% on the header and live /our-story; FAQ lists the defunct 'Amazon Checkout'. Footer 'Blogs' link goes to a charity blog whose last post is Aug 2021. Live footer not verifiable (Cloudflare)
5.7Structured data (Organization/LocalBusiness) correct on core facts
1 partialOrganization JSON-LD present with only name, url and logo (no address, phone, sameAs or areaServed). Product pages carry full Product/Offer JSON-LD
Checks that scored a miss or a partial outside the listing cleanup.
Order intake automation
1.2Punch-out / eProcurement catalog confirmed on a named buyer platform
0 missNo punch-out / cXML / eProcurement catalog on own site; no buyer punch-out list names Zuma (web search 2026-11-18)
Order intake automation
1.3Purchase orders captured at checkout rather than emailed as documents
1 partialApproved-account POs can be placed on the website OR by phone, fax or email; no-account POs must be faxed/emailed as signed documents
Order intake automation
1.4Fax is not an ordering channel
0 missContact page: 'Fax*: 1-512-593-5596 *You may fax in orders at this number'; school PO page also directs faxed orders
Order intake automation
1.6Company-stated online share of orders or revenue
1 partialCompany-stated 80% of business online (Independent Dealer, Jun 2024)
Order intake automation
1.7Self-serve ordering is the primary path (phone/email secondary)
1 partialPhone, 'Chat live' and email shown beside the cart as equal channels; site promises 'Customer Service that really listens (and answers the phone)'; schools/government order by phone, fax or email
Pricing & contract accuracy
2.6Fee, surcharge and shipping-threshold policies consistent across pages
0 missFAQ says $8.99 shipping under $75 and $69.95 / 10% freight; Shipping Policy says $9.99 ($45-75), $13.99 (<$45) and $84.95 / 13% freight. Both captured 25 May 2022; FAQ text unchanged in Jul 2025; no later readable Shipping Policy capture
Customer retention / win-back
3.2Saved lists/favorites and standing or managed replenishment offered
1 partialFavorites lists and Quick Order form offered; no standing/managed replenishment program described (product-page template carries subscription styling but no offer text was visible)
Back office (AP/AR)
4.2Net terms / credit set up digitally (instant online credit or online application)
1 partialSchools/government: create account, then contact customer service to finish setup (Net 30); Zuma+ customers 'may apply for 30-day invoicing'; business terms via credit application forwarded by email
Back office (AP/AR)
4.3Payment and financing pages current and consistent
1 partialFAQ (Jul 2025) still lists 'Amazon Checkout' (Checkout by Amazon ended in the U.S. in April 2017) and money orders/cashier's checks before shipment
Customer service responsiveness
6.2Published weekday support hours
1 partialOffice hours 8:30 am-5:00 pm Central, Mon-Fri (8.5 h)
Customer service responsiveness
6.3After-hours or weekend coverage (staffed, bot, or stated SLA)
0 missBusiness hours only; no after-hours channel stated
Customer service responsiveness
6.6Independent review rating
1 partialeKomi 4.3/5 from 32 reviews in last 12 months (95.9% positive); 6,094 lifetime. Yelp via Yahoo 4.0 on 5 reviews
Reporting / visibility
7.1Customer-facing purchase/spend reports advertised
1 partialOrder history plus 'set budgets' (FAQ); no spend reports advertised
Reporting / visibility
7.4Named operations leader (COO / GM / ops manager)
1 partialMason Kramer is listed as President and COO in one directory and President and CEO in another, so the operations title is publicly unclear.
AI & search visibility
8.1Share of tested buyer-style AI queries naming the company
1 partialNamed in 1 of 4 buyer-style queries (charity-giving query); not named for 'best online office supply Houston', 'bulk janitorial/breakroom free shipping', or 'auto dealer key tags/windshield highlights'. Factual query 'who owns Zuma' named it (2026-11-18)
scorecard 8 (AI test, 2026-11-18)
AI & search visibility
8.2Facts in AI answers about the company correct
0 missAn AI answer repeated an older charity share. The company's current pages say 10%.
scorecard 8 (AI test, 2026-11-18)
AI & search visibility
8.6Buyer-question content published in the last 12 months (guides/FAQ/blog)
0 missCharity blog last posted Aug 3 2021; no guides/FAQ articles in the last 12 months found
Current revenue after 2025 is not stated. The revenue of the division bought in May 2026 is not disclosed. Average order value, the contract-price share, and the current wholesaler are assumptions or unpublished. Several comparisons use archived pages because the live site did not respond.
The low and high cases move the published benchmark bands. They do not also swing revenue or order count. The high side of the pricing leak and of churn stays at the benchmark median.
checklist v2: category pct = points / (2 x known criteria); unknowns excluded; category needs >=3 known criteria; overall = mean of graded category pct Overall C+ is 63.5% across the categories that earned a letter. Coverage is 40 of 53 criteria (75%). Pricing has no letter.
Edits stay in this browser tab. Refresh or Reset puts the published figures back. This page has no form and no tracking. Nothing you type is sent anywhere.
A short look, with you, at one back-office job that would give the reps more time on the phone. No chatbot on the line. No form on this page.
Book a 20-minute walkthrough